From The
Boston Globe:
Cure is hit or
miss on diverse bill
By Tom Kielty, Globe Correspondent
| August 9, 2004
MANSFIELD -- The sun battling against a gray
sky provided an ideal setting for the Curiosa Festival at the Tweeter Center
on Saturday. In the midst of a dismal summer concert season, this ambitious
outing of eight bands proved an impressive success, even if the headlining
set by the Cure was clouded at times by a determination to introduce material
from their latest release, simply titled "The Cure."
The goth heavyweights played for an audience
that was easily the biggest of the day, though not near the venue's capacity,
with many fans arriving only for their headlining set and blowing off what
was a wonderfully diverse bill.
For longtime fans, the Cure's set was a mixed
bag. "Lovesong," driven by a prominent bass line, was followed quickly
by the terrifically dour "In Between Days." The show reached its first
peak when the band continued with "Just Like Heaven" as iconic frontman
Robert Smith, in signature lipstick, eye shadow, and teased hair, gave the
tune an extended ending on acoustic guitar.
Unfortunately this threesome was sandwiched
by new, lesser-known material, and many in attendance grew impatient. The
club beats and ringing guitars of "A Forest" proved an impressive remedy,
but ultimately the set was plagued by the hits' being left behind in lieu
of new songs.
For those who had arrived early, however, there
was an abundance of vibrant new music by bands -- all selected by Smith
-- who have embraced the Cure's alter-ethos. An expansive second stage set
in the Tweeter's parking lot flowed seamlessly with the main stage, and
a crowd that ranged from old-time goth rockers to parents chaperoning children
moved with ease between the two performance spaces.
The earliest of these arrivals were greeted
by sheets of guitar rock from Scotland's Mogwai, following an introductory
second-stage set by Head Automatica. Mogwai's main-stage set showed a beauty
in noise that at points recalled My Bloody Valentine. The proceedings then
moved back to the lot, where the Cooper Temple Clause managed to showcase
an ambient mood, albeit a loud ambience, that was at times driven by four
guitars and at others by synthesizer and keyboards.
The Rapture was the first band to benefit from
the removal of seats by the stage, as a dancing "pit area" embraced
its punchy beats. The action then moved back outside as Auf der Maur, the
latest project from onetime Smashing Pumpkins and Hole member Melissa Auf
der Maur, showcased a guitar-driven sound that paid homage to her earlier
work but grew monotonous.
This was followed by Interpol's main-stage performance.
The debonair rockers introduced new songs that draw from the same winning
Joy Division-influenced sound that fueled their debut, "Turn on the Bright
Lights."
The Muse was the final act to play on the second
stage and the only to benefit from darkness. The British threesome put
the lack of daylight to good use, punctuating their energetic set with a
brilliant light show that was only marred by attendees' quick exits in anticipation
of the Cure's headlining set.
© Copyright 2004 Globe
Newspaper Company.
(Thanks Michael)
I am just now coming down to earth a bit after the Curiosa festival
this last weekend in Mansfield (although I just want it to go on and on!).
I wanted to tell all of you to have a great time when you go see the festival
in other cities. Be sure to arrive early enough to see all the other bands.
In my experience, Mogwai was utterly fantastic. They must be heard live as
their albums cannot come close to matching the intensity of their live sound.
They came out right after their act to see the Cooper Temple Clause performing
on the second stage and I got to compliment them briefly as they
stood on the sidelines. Unfortunately many of the bands playing before The
Cure did not attract appreciative audience and Mogwai, being the first act
to play on the main stage, had very few listeners (they played right after
Head Automatica on the second stage, also under-attended). Don't miss any
of them!
The fans in Boston were a bit quiet - or something - during all the pre-Cure
acts. I was enjoying the entire show but noticed many people were just
milling about looking almost bored, also a majority arrived late only to
see The Cure, so they forfeited the whole point of the festival. However when
The Cure took stage the crowd woke up and came alive. Everyone was on their
feet the whole time (at least where we were). You can read all the reviews
and see what others think but parts of these reviews are so blasted nit-picky
and seem to miss the point or focus only on the superficial, when
there are other, certainly more worthwhile, experiences that should be mentioned.
I personally tire of reading the same negatives about not hearing
a fav song, hating/not wanting to hear the new or pop songs or about Robert
missing words on the lyrics, etc...my god it is a live concert, and doesn't
anyone believe in creative license? The Cure played from their soul, explored
a wide range of emotions with their music, and it all was so very
memorable.
Lost set a very somber mood to begin, lest we forget that dark and hopeless
feelings are frequently at the heart of Cure music. When the bleak agony of
songs such as Lost are juxtaposed with some very hopeful buoyant feelings
in other songs (especially as in this set, when Lost was sharply contrasted
by directly following it with Plainsong), this creates a strange dizzy sense
of ambivalence that is a mark of The Cure's unique signature. By ambivalence,
I mean that the listener is so assaulted with strongly conflicting emotions
that you are left drained and not knowing what to feel, but thereafter, it
almost has a cleaning effect and you can sense the simultaneously conflicting
emotions in the music more intensely. Indeed it is worth
mentioning that creation of this ambivalence forms the nexus of Robert's
mature musical expression. Lost made me feel utterly and uncomfortably alone
while surrounded by a large concert crowd. Perhaps this might be the helplessly
bitter human emotion that Robert is trying to evoke in those who are willing
to let it in. Listening to this song on a stereo in your safe and secure little
home would never capture the same stark experience while
hearing it live surrounded by a large focused audience. However, the majority
of the crowd can't seem to embrace the painful despair of Lost (and
most seem repulsed by it); the song is NOT pleasant, after all, if one is
only listening to satisfy shallow entertainment values. Many in the crowd
have their minds all caught up in the anxious hours before The Cure takes
stage, then are so frenetically intent on hearing that One Fav Tune once the
band steps out and takes their instruments; the sad result for those fans
is that much of the depth of The Cure concert experience passes them by.
If the set list you hear begins with Lost, try not to miss the raw soul-numbing/life
affirming experience Robert might offer you at the beginning of the show.
In Mansfield, he ruthlessly drew everyone down into the despairing, almost
inescapable black depths of Lost and then flung us soaring up into the exquisitely
crystalline-sweet relief of Plainsong; it was a brilliant marriage of two
opposing forces, so well done and complete.
I won't bother to comment on the rest of this wonderful concert, much has
already been said by others. I only wanted to offer with this review a
different opinion about Lost as the opening song.
- aroid
Like most of you, I was very mixed about this festival. It was cool to check
out some new bands (The Rapture, Interpol, and CTC were very good), but at
the expense of a much shorter Cure set than I am used to? I also decided not
to go to more than the one show this time around for this and other reasons.
I was not happy they didn't come on until 9:20 even though everything was
set by 9 and Muse had already stopped playing. but anyway
Lost - I know I will probably get The Promise, but I can't get into this
song. Robert really feels this one though.
Plainsong - Very surprised to hear this in the same set and was really
hoping for SDS, It sounded great though.
Fascination Street - Good version - Perry's guitar too low.
TEOTW - This song is starting to grow on me and sounded good here.
Anniversary - One of my faves from the new record, good performance.
Lovesong, IBD, JLH - gotta have singles, right? a lot of the real pop was
last show - these ones are alright with me.
Jupiter crash - Nice surprise and sounded good. I love this song and you
can tell that Robert does too.
Pictures Of You - good, crowd likes it a lot.
Before Three - I don't know about this song, I don't hate it but?
FTEOTDGS - Powerful, Perry a little low in the mix again - what is up with
that?
Disintegration - I have this weird thing with this song live. It is one
of my absolute favorite songs ever, but it just never sounds exactly right.
I can't explain it. The mix is always just a little off or I am or something.
The last time it sounded perfect to me was '92. I also look like a fool
that doesn't know the words to a song they're singing, but try telling people
it's the singer, not you :)
One Hundred Years - Great as always, made me want more from Pornography
The Promise - OMFG! Can't even describe how good this was - an instant
live classic.
M - This is the best live version of M I have ever heard.
Play For Today - Love this song - good performance.
A Forest - This song is sacred to me. Remember when it was almost always
the last song? Short but powerful - Simon's bass and Roberts guitar
amazing. Did I start the clapping first? I like to think so :)
Going Nowhere - I have the double LP and this is on it. My favorite next
to the Promise. It sounded very good even though it was hurried.
I think this was a good show overall. It was not as great or long as I've
been to many times before, but I appreciate and respect what they are doing.
I hope they come back after the festival. If they do, I will probably go
to 2 or 3 shows. I haven't heard SDS or Faith live since '85, maybe the 10th
or 11th try since will give them to me - It's just a matter of time:)
- Doug
Well, my Cure adventure started last Sunday night, when I watched them
preform at the Tweeter Center in NJ. Awesome show! Still feel
the CURE
when I hear Plainsong, the lights, music, very happy expierence!
I took my 19 year old step brother, needless to say, he has been Curified!
I got the set list, too cool!
Ok, next it was on to Columbia, Md for the 2nd concert. Out of the
9 shows since the WISH tour, it was by far the best time I ever had.
I got Rogers autograph, I fell in love with my best friend of ten years,
who was just a buddy till I kissed her during Lullaby, I don't know if it
was the atmoshpere, the music, but once was a friendship, The Cure pushed
me into her. Awesome feeling, The Cure there again to help me thru my life,
as since 1989! So I got the set list again, and then stayed up till
4 with her talking about the show, and getting another person into The Cure.
After waking up at 10am, I got $25.00 dollars special lawn seats at Mansfield,
a 6.3hr ride according to mapquest...ended up 8hrs, with traffice jams in
Rhode Island?!!!!! After getting there all by myself, the whole mood
there just sucked, the people there were rude, and it wasn't even packed
out, what the f**k?! After listening to the new album, I wasn't a big
fan of all the songs, but after hearing them live these three dates, I fell
in love with the new material. the final song was great, but couple
of the songs Robert guitar did not seem to operate the way he wanted and it
showed. Seemed very rushed. But I must say, Pics of You, takes
me back everytime! Now if I can just find a way to see them on the
west coast or overseas, it will complete me!!!!
- Chris
Saturday, August 7th, 2004. Mansfield, Mass. Fourth show.
~*~ l o s s . f o r . w o r d s ~*~
What a disaster. I am still trying to figure out what happened Saturday
night.... Partly the reason I feel so 'lost' writing this is due to the
fact the drive from Baltimore to Boston took ten and a half hours. Yes. Ten.
and. a. Half. Hours. How? I haven't a clue. We arrived at the venue at 8:45ish.
Rushing inside, oddly enough, we run into quite a few people who were also
at last nights show. Telling these people our ride took 11hours they were
looking to me as if I had 4 heads. Most seemed to have gotten there from
MD between 6 and 8 hours. Don't ask...... Mass is very, uhm, proper.....?
Felt very out of place as a sleezy nyc boy in that 'new england' area. Buying
alcohol past 11pm? HEAVEN FORBID. The whole state seemed to have been shutdown
by 1am. Wasn't comfortable up there, at all.
The venue seemed nice, big as well. This was my first time there. I
didn't get to see it in the light. The seating looked rather empty compared
to the last few shows..... Again with the alcohol laws, they would not serve
me their overpriced beer, as I didn't have 2 forms of ID since I was from
'out of state' Not a problem, I was able to get 2 drinks in me before the
show started. The show started late at that... So I get to my seat, I wasn't
happy with it. I had 2nd row on Roberts side. I was expecting to be maybe
5 feet to the left of him, turned out being about 10 or 15 feet to the left
of him. Again, never been to this venue before (note to self: do not rely
on seating charts) So I was upset over this too. So I managed to con my
way into the pit, it was too crowded, walked right back out. Also, I was
not relaxed due to all the rushing to get there. Every other show I was
completely relaxed and
ready for everything. Mansfield I wasn't, thus my review will probably
be biased from this, something I can only blame myself for, but this is
how I saw the show, in all honesty. I have read the reviews as well, I usually
don't read them before I write mine. I like to do them without bias or
influence, most of you seem to have enjoyed the show, unfortunately, I
can't say I fully enjoyed it. Mmmmm, okay, on with the review.
Took the stage with Lost a few minutes late. Still comparing things
to last night when they started way earlier, this did not put me in a good
frame of mind. I also have a problem with opening the set with Lost, I don't
think it brings forth a good emotion to start the show with, so I went
to get another drink. So I'm walking back to my seat, grumbling, drinking
nasty beer, listening to the end of Lost. Which quite honestly, didn't
sound that bad~!! Also noticed that my seat was damn close to Robert and
I should stop my whining.
Plainsong, might this save the show? Doubtful. Plainsong sounded great
however, could not save this set... A previous reviewer said he saw the
Anniversary sign stage left and the Faith sign in the pit. Not really.
I was left with the Faith sign, and I assume the Anniversary sign was
in the pit. And I already apologized to him for ripping off the idea,
but I will do so publicly as well. I was (and still am) in desperation
to hear Faith again before the West coast shows~! I know now that it's
going to happen =/ Robert did come over to me looking at the sign.
I of course walked up to the gate, he didn't smile, he looked to me, his
eyes lit up, his mouth was open, he looked as if he didn't know what to
say, we stared at each other for a few seconds, then he put his arms up,
someone threw a teddy bear at him and he walked away. Quite possible the
highlight of the show along with Going Nowhere. I don't recall a rodie holding
up a paper last night. I did walk away for a moment during end/world....
Fascination Street. I knew I couldn't be so lucky to get two shows
in a row with no FasciSt. So I took it with a grain of salt, and danced
to it for the 92347629476270570th time =) The End of the World. Don't like
this song much. Live version doesn't save it. Not being impressed with this
show. Was I spoiled from NJ & MD? Or just in a poor mood overall? Not
quite sure, but I do know this set reminded me all too much of the NYC show....
Things started to pick up here. Anniversary was great, this was the
best I've heard this song played so far. Lovesong, Inbeween, and JLH....
Couldn't get more predictable.... Love them all though, sounded great,
nothing to stop me from dancing..... Jupiter Crash was beautiful, SO happy
this is being played so frequently, didn't know if this one would have
ever been brought back from the WMS burial site. Hopefully this one sticks
around with Want.... A F***ing FABULOUS Pictures of You~!!! At this point
I was completely enjoying the show. It got off to a very rough start, all
was well now. Before three finally sounded excellent, * almost * as good
as Coachella and HFStival, almost... Pretty sure he got all the lyrics correct
this time, even the "yeah yeah yeahs". DGS was the usual, not too many hands
in the sky though....... Disintegration was good, not as good as the night
before, great nonetheless, one of my fav songs, I don't care how slow it's
played or how many lyrics are wrong, I love it no matter what. 100yrs was
perfect. By this time the person in the seat in front of me left and I made
it into the front row~! =)) Really enjoyed the Promise last night. Puts new
meaning and emotion into that song playing it live. Truly comes to life,
and the solo at the end * swoon * One of the better versions of this song
I've heard. Main set done. Seemed to go all too quickly.
Encore..... Was hoping to hear Faith and Charlotte. Nope. They go into
the standard 17sec encore, as played in NYC. Too many similarities to
NYC for it's own good.... The encore sounded great. Like hearing M
live more than anything. Play for Today was wonderful, but not many " whoaaa
ooooohhh ooooh's" I'm jaded with A Forest, the shortened version to
comply with these curfews does not do the usual live version justice anyway.
Lots of clapping at the end which was nice to see. So I thought it was over.
Not yet.... He comes back out and starts talking about the curfew, blah
blah blah, they're going to pull the plug, blah blah blah, we have 2 mins
left. I was sure he was going to close with BDC. He grabs the Guild 12string,
announces " Going Nowhere " <3 I couldn't believe this. I got so
happy so quick. I started screaming, jumping, and just spamming in general.
At one point I must have jumped about 4 feet in the air, lost control, and
landed on a security guard!!! *L* I thought to myself OH NO! NOW IM GOING
TO GET KICKED OUT AND MISS THE BEST SONG OF THE EVENING!!!!! So then I apologize
to the guy, and he didn't really say anything....... That song is so beautiful,
I just stood there speechless as if my mind had shut off and gone into shock,
overwhelmed by this gorgeous song that I have never heard live. Going Nowhere
is another one that cuts right through you. That song alone was worth going
to this show.
Now the show is over, already? Yes, already =(* I wasn't impressed
with it, too close to NYC, horrible setlist with the exception of a few
songs. It was all too predictable and a very basic stripped down version
of the Curiosa set. After coming up to this show from last nights 2 hour
show, that rates right up there with proper Cure shows, it was hard to go
into this one with an open mind. The first show has been the lesser of the
back to back nights so far, 'tis easier to see a better show the second night
than the first. If I had gotten there earlier, before Interpol, would have
been perfect, and would have enjoyed myself a lot more. Not a bad show, not
a great show. Was hard to top, or even come close, to last nights show. Had
I walked into this one after a break, would have liked it a lot more. The
setlist was very weak.... Going Nowhere was a treat..... I don't know. Nothing
more I can Say...
See you all in Phoenix~!!! =)
- SugarandOpium
I was at the Festival, but only saw the Cure.
My friend (not much of a Cure fan...yet) and I arrived at 5:00, but spent
the next 4 hours chilling
in the lot (those $8 beers are a killer). Since we only had lawn
seats (purchased on a WBCN promotion for 10.50) I didn't worry much about
getting
our $$'s worth on the other bands, none of which we knew a single note.
We could hear some of the other bands, but didn't pay much attention.
On
Sunday, I regretted it a bit that we didn't hear more bands, but who
has time for regrets? Especially when the Cure sounded so good.
I think the above set list was good, but would have liked to have heard
'Strange Day' and 'Open'. When they played those two songs at this
venue
on the Dream tour, they were awesome. 'Jupiter Crash' was a good
call, since it is not often played; if I could have picked a song from that
album, it would have been the 13th (has that ever been played live?) and
would have settled for 'Round and Round', 'Trap' or even 'Strange Attraction'.
The hightpoints were 'Plainsong', 'Inbetween Days' (my introduction to the
band {thanks V66} and still fave) and '100 Years'. The new songs sounded
good and presented a good summary of the new disc. I look forward
to a full tour by the Cure; I think the whole album live would give a better
appreciation of the feel of it.
From our point on the lawn, the sound was really great. I've only
seen them 7 times now, starting in 1989 (the last two dates of the the
Prayer tour at this venue) and, barring the hiccup in 1996 in Worcester
(first date of the American tour, I believe) they have sounded progressively
better. It seems like a shorter set list than other dates so far,
but they did some longer songs (plainsong, disintegration, 100 years, From
the Edge). The punchline was I had listened to the '17 Seconds' disc
that morning for breakfast (my 2 year old daughter liked 'Play for Today'),
so it paid off for the encore. I didn't really miss Robert's chatter;
as another reviewer noted, I usually can't understand him anyway.
What's up with the 'you guys were fucking awesome!'? Is that now a
staple of each show? I liked his comment about having the plug pulled,
and then they snuck in 'Going Nowhere', which I have only heard once, when
WBWC did their 18 hour tribute. I liked it, very emotional and heavy.
It was a great show, I just wish it had been a full set, they sounded
that good. My friend was quite impressed; he didn't know the band
very well, but as luck would have it, he had met Robert in 1997 during Goldfinger's
show at the Middle East in Cambridge. That was after the Cure played
the Orpheum in Boston as part of WBCN's Xmas Rave. I saw that
Orpheum show and it was great (especially after the mess in Worcester '96)
and afterwards, Robert crossed the River to check out Goldfinger; another
friend of ours got her pic with Robert, who was, as always, willing
to be polite to a fan. Well, I'm happy to say my friend's now a convert
and I'm really psyched to say that the Cure just keep getting better.
Much thanks to them.
- Michael Lyons
After spending so much time and money on major trips to Coachella and
WHFS, I really only had the energy to see the New York Curiosa date (I
live in Manhattan). I told myself that if the NYC show absolutely blew
me away, I would consider renting a car and catching the Maryland or the
Mansfield show. Well, the exact opposite happened. The
NYC show left me wanting so much more. It was just so painful to
see the setlist the next night in Camden... then reading the Cuyahoga Falls
setlist made things worse.
I nearly had a nervous breakdown during the week stressing over whether
to see another show... checking ebay over and over again for good seats...
checking rental car prices...trying to decide between Columbia and Mansfield...
I almost couldn't sleep a few nights. I didn't want to spend all
the money and drive an 8 hour roundtrip to see the exact same setlist.
Shouldn't I just save the money for their next tour, which hopefully won't
be a festival? AHHHH! The indecision! Ticketmaster releasing
PIT seats for Columbia and great seats at Mansfield in the 11th hour made
me stress even more.
I ended up finding a friend who was a casual Cure fan who wanted to
make the Saturday roadtrip to Mansfield with me. Ticketmaster had great
$50 seats in the section 6, the center section right behind the soundboard.
So I took the bus to LaGuardia, rented a car, picked up my friend in
Brooklyn and made the 4 hour trek.
We arrived right after the Rapture had ended. Kudos to the Tweeter
Center for having free parking. Shame on them for their $8 beer.
We made our way to our seats and were decently satisfied. I just
knew that there would be tons of empty seats up close. All of the
fucking ticket brokers
who bought up the good seats and couldn't sell them at their outrageous
prices weren't going to be there sitting in them. I just don't understand
how concert tickets work. Why does Tickemaster suddenly have good seats
the week of? How do the Pit seats sell out in 10 seconds? How
do the
brokers get so many seats? So ridiculous, all of it.
Anyway, I *highly* recommend that those of you going to shows on the
rest of the tour do your best to upgrade your seats. All you have
to do is wait for the ushers to distract themselves with other patrons and
waltz right by. We were busted by one usher on the audience left side of
the theatre, but we just played dumb and kept walking. Once we got to
the other side the ushers weren't even paying attention. We made our
way do dead center, 3 rows back from the PIT, where there was perfect stereo
sound and plenty of space to move around. As someone else mentioned
there was an enormous amount of empty seats around us. Such a shame!
Anyway, Interpol put on a good show. In NYC their show was 30
minutes earlier and it was too light out for them to use any lights.
Their light show was fantastic and really added to the experience.
I wasn't able to get to the internet Saturday morning, so I had absolutely
no idea what was played in Maryland. This was a good thing, because
I really had no way to predict the setlist.
The low last night was 53. It was cold, dark, and it looked
like rain. Surely my dream would come true and they would open with
Plainsong! I had heard it once before as an encore in the Dream
Tour Chicago show, but I wanted it again so badly. At 9:20 the band
was nowhere in sight. I don't known why they started late...
They only have until 11! Why would they start late!? This
whole festival situation is so maddening. A roadie came out with
a bottle of wine and poured it into several dixie cups for Robert to later
drink out of. The rest of the band seemed to be drinking water.
They are using DJ Shadow's "Private Press" album as house music for this
tour. There is also a pre-show song they play immediately before
the Cure comes
out. It's instrumental and lasts for just a couple of minutes.
The show finally started at 9:23 or so and I told my friend, "If Robert
comes out last, I'm getting thet song I want." Of course he didn't.
They went right into "Lost" and I was feeling terrible. I just knew
I would get the exact same setlist I got a week prior in NYC and my entire
trip would have been a waste. To be fair, it was a fabulous version
of "Lost", much better than NYC with Robert actually getting close to the
intensity of the
"third gear" part of the song as he does on the album. Then it ended
and a black scrim started to come down to cover the white sheets.
What? They didn't have a scrim in NYC... then the white lights started
to flicker and the chimes were heard... it still took me a few seconds
to figure out what was happening as I had completely written "Plainsong"
off when they didn't open with it. But I was wrong! I jumped
up and down and yelled like crazy. Just pure beauty. Robert walking
to stage left and shaking as many hands as he could. Then doing the
same for stage right in the outro. Just a beautiful time... Someone
complained about the lights, but I loved them. The flickering whites
were just beautiful.
Next came Fascination Street. I'm so over this song. I've
just heard it too many times. Cure fans need to come up with some
audience participation for songs like this. Like, I love the hands in the
air bit on FTEOTDGS... there should be something we all do during Fascination...something
to spice up this mainstay. Like, let's all pump our fists during
"move to the beat". Something!
I think I saw the guys with the "Play Anniversary" sign audience left.
I couldn't actually read the sign. It looked like Robert gave them
a smile during "Plainsong" indicating they would get their wish. There
was someone with a "Faith" sign in the center of the Pit. Roger
had a roadie write "NO" on a white sheet of paper. After the roadie
handed it to him he flashed it at the poster holders. Pretty funny,
though sad to find out that we
would get no "Faith"!
TEOTW - boring. They should project the video for this behind
them. Something. This song doesn't nothing for me live.
Anniversary - Nice to hear for the first time. I like it better
live than on the album. They projected "7 August 2004" on the sheets.
Very cool.
Lovesong - so stale and boring. Waste of precious time.
Inbetween Days - got the crowd rocking.
JLH - wonderful as always.
Jupiter Crash - a nice surprise. Plantetary imagery projected.
The crowd seemed confused. Many sat down. I enjoyed it.
Pictures - great as always.
Before 3 - Robert got to the first "yeah yeah yeah"s for a change.
This sounded better than the 3 other times I've heard it. Love the
golden / moon imagery.
FEOTDGS - the best live song in the Cure's catalog. Hands up
in the Pit... not too many in the back.
Disintegration - Very happy to get to hear this... but it really wasn't
as strong as it has been in the past. Robert didn't seem to know
many of the words and it really detracted from it. Also Simon's bass
was really loud and abrasive... I know the bass drives this song, but it
just didn't sound right to me. It picked up by the end with the "always,
always" section.
100 Years - They really love playing this song, and they really rock
it hard. However, I think it would be a good idea to sub it out of
the list every now and then, just for variety's sake. Tonight's set,
although it did have it's surprises was still a bit formulaic. The
Cure have such a massive catalog... it would be great if even the hardcore
COF readers couldn't predict what song was coming next.
The Promise - Awesome. Lots of people sitting down when it started--
casual fans who didn't know what it was or were tired of all of the dirges
in a row-- but by the end, everyone was on their feet. This song
has such an excellent build. Perry had a string hanging lose towards
the end. He didn't care. Robert wailed away on his guitar.
The feedback remained with us as the band left (much like Mogwai tends to
do!).
When they returned for the encore Robert said something like, "I'm
sorry I haven't really communicated with you all much tonight. Apart
from singing, of course." The scrim came up, and I just knew a big
red "M" would be there soon enough. I was right. This was a
drag for me as I heard
the 17 Seconds encore last week. "M" was actually surprisingly
aggressive. Much better than in NYC. "Play for Today" was fine.
The sound was so loud where I was I couldn't tell if anyone was singing
along to the keyboards. "Forest" rocked. Lots of handclapping.
I looked at my watch. 11:02. ARGH. Why did they
start so late!?!?!? Robert came back and said they had 2 minutes...I
just knew we would get "Boys Don't Cry" but was thrilled when "Going Nowhere"
was played. Very pretty. Nice way to end the evening.
All in all it was worth the trek to see 4 different songs, a better
sound mix, and better seats. A good evening. Of course when
I got back and saw that Columbia had 14 different songs from NYC my heart
was a little broken yet again.
Please play an indoor tour in the states this winter/fall!!!
- Charlie Todd
I attented the show this past Saturday in Mansfield, MA. and experienced
another amazing performance by THE CURE. I was probably, one of only
what seemed like a few fans actually dancing, jumping, moving, in general
(maintaining an active pulse) during their performance. I must say
to the same degree that I have never been disappointed by attending a CURE
show, I also HAVE NEVER NOT BEEN DISAPPOINTED WITH THE CROWD!!!
ONCE AGAIN INCREDIBLY PATHETIC AND EVEN WORSE, APATHETIC!!
Luckily, I was with my sister and 2 other friends
who all tried to give back some energy to the band. Also, one
true fan behind me who knew how to get into the music. I am always
amazed that
during "Play for Today" , more of the crowd doesn't catch on to the
classic soccer style chant that is supposed to be shouted by the audience
(see the Paris live album) at various points throughtout the song.
Anyways, thoroughly enjoyed the show regardless. Although, for
show #8 I will definitely be heading over to England to experience the
real deal.
- Jared Mancini
I just got back from the Mansfield show and I can say that I have
made peace with the latest album. Lost turned out to be a brilliant opener.
TEOTW–Anniversary was a great tandem. Before Three and the Promise
came to life in a way that didn’t on the CD. The rest of the set was stacked
with old standbys which I’m sure many of us have heard live a few
times. There was no surprise Bananafishbones or Meathook. I didn’t mind
though.
They presented the new material well. Any forward thinking band should
open a set with a new song and instead of shoehorning Boys Don’t Cry
into the last two minutes before the establishment threatened to
as Robert said "pull the plug" we got a song missing from the American
release. A poignant Going Nowhere which I had never heard before and was
introduced live.
Oh, and I picked up a Muse album this morning after being very impressed.
- Peter Severy
You could tell it was going to be a pop-heavy night because of the
wonderful weather and the gorgeous double rainbow in the sky next to
the huge
raincloud that stayed far away...the band was super-tight, the sound
was much better if you weren't close to the stage. Highlights were
great
performances of Plainsong, Pix of You, Promise, M and A Forest,
with Robert finishing with the decelerating up-and-down-the-guitar distortion
like the end of the "Show" live version. JLH was impassioned and
wonderful. But hearing "Going Nowhere" live was worth the price of
admission! And Simon was like a man possessed tonight, absolutely
blazing; actually all of them during the end of 100 Years were in that zone,
they looked like they were on a crazed dancefloor somewhere with their instruments
as their partners.
Robert didn't talk at all during the show except near the end when
he apologized for not being very communicative. Before "Going Nowhere"
he said that instead of fining you for breaking curfew some places just
pull the plugs, so they had about 2 minutes.
The new songs were MUCH better live than on the cd. On cd
"Anniversary" has atmosphere - live, it has majesty. The individual
song sections contained more excitement, letting you appreciate how they
are structured even more.
So overall, up there with the best Cure shows I've seen in terms
of playing, and after the lovely festival day, I didn't mind the set list
at all.
- Justin Budinoff
What an incredible night!
We get there shortly after the doors opened. My boyfriend
and I had seats in Section 1, but I went over to the box office and ended
up scoring the last pit ticket! I was beyond excited about this.
We watched all the first stage bands together from our seats. Mogwai
was really good and I was glad to have a chance to hear them as I didn’t
know their music. They might be the sort of band that is better to
listen to on CD at home rather than live, at least for me. But still
good. The Rapture was better than I expected and fun. Interpol,
one of my favorites, was fantastic. They played three songs from
the new album too which was a treat. The lighting for them was particularly
good as well. Heard a little bit of the second stage bands, the best
of which I thought was the Cooper Temple Clause.
The merchandise stand was well stocked. Had a large array
of t-shirts, some tanks, some girl’s shirts. Had the tour books,
hats, bags, buttons, keychains, mousepads, tattoo sets, wallets, etc.
Now on to the important stuff.
My boyfriend stayed in the section seat while I went down to the
pit for the whole Cure set (he’s a really nice guy). I had never
been that close to them before and it was absolutely incredible.
The band came out and Robert (wearing lots of eye make-up) walked around
in front of the stage for a minute, looking at the audience with silly
weird expression on his face. He did a little classic Robert dance
move for someone in the crowd and laughed.
Robert’s voice was incredibly strong and clear and fantastic.
The sound mixing sounded really good to my ears. They all played
brilliantly. As
far as I was concerned, it was perfection.
They opened with Lost. It was even better than the album.
I was especially curious to hear how this would sound live this night
(after the stifling HFStival where it didn’t come across as well) and was
completely impressed.
The Plainsong. Beautiful. What else is there to say.
Next was Fascination Street, which the crowd (rather sedate for
the most part) really got into. I think this is a great live song
and tonight was no exception.
Followed by The End of the World, which was not the best performance
of the song but still quite good.
Then one of the best songs of the night, Anniversary. This
sounded amazing live, absolutely fantastic. I’m so glad they played
this and I love the song more than ever now.
The pop songs came next with the ever present Lovesong, Inbetween
Days and Just Like Heaven. All the usual sounds but there are great
sounds
and made the crowd happy. And watching Simon dance a bit
to Inbetween Days was very cute. He plays with his usual scowl
but every once in a
while breaks into a smile during the middle of it and this was
one of those times.
Another highlight of the night for me was Jupiter Crash, in my
opinion one of their most beautiful songs ever and was flawless.
Then another crowd pleaser with the usual (and still good) Pictures
of You.
Not many songs from the new album overall but we got Before Three
as one of them and with particularly impassioned singing from Robert.
Wonderful to hear.
The real crux of the show was the next four songs – From the Edge
of the Deep Green Sea, Disintegration, One Hundred Years and The Promise.
During these songs the boys really seem to come alive, particularly
the last two. Perry broke a guitar string on The Promise.
Perry and Simon
completely jamming into One Hundred Years. I feel like that
song has experienced a rebirth from how much it blasts open and through
you they way they’ve been playing it lately. The Promise is even
better after this lead up. I don’t think Robert is ever happier on
stage then when playing the guitar in The Promise. These last four
songs were an amazing powerhouse and really made the show.
The first encore was predictable but never gets old for me.
M, Play for Today and A Forest. Not a very long Forest but they
had already broken
curfew at this point. When Robert first came out for the
encore, he said something about not having conversed much with the audience
(which was true) but that’s okay. I can’t understand what he says
much of the time inbetween songs anyway. Play for Today was particularly
good. I’ve always thought A Forest was a great song to end a Cure
show with so when they finished that, I figured that was it and was quite
happy with the whole night with the exception of not having heard the one
song I wanted most to hear…. They walked off the stage and then almost
immediately came back out again. Robert said something about it was
hard to break curfew because of having to pay for it and all so they only
had about two minutes for one more song, one he said they haven’t played
much….and it was the one song I wanted with all my heart to hear… Going
Nowhere. I could have cried I was so happy. It was short but
stunningly beautiful and made the night for me. Well, that and having
a very good close view of Perry : )
All in all, there is not a thing I would complain about.
When I heard them play at the Tweeter Center for the Dream Tour, I remember
thinking how absolutely clear and strong and incredible they sounded and
tonight was if anything even better. It’s a great place to hear them
and it was a great show. I’m truly happy.
- Birdmad9
Ok so The show was a little later than 9:15 to start and we were
getting anxious given all the curfew talk. But soon enough it started.
I don't want to bore you with a song by song breakdown...suffice to say
the boys are rockin on this little tour. they are tight, happy and smoking.
I have to believe the other bands on the tour are giving them a little
motivation to rock just a little harder...overall the show was awesome.
Robert, Simon and Perry all had a little technical trouble at different
points toward the encores.. Perry broke a string he was playing so hard
on Promise, and Simon kicked his bass at one point on his way off stage...?
the highlight for me was from ...the Edge to the Promise these four songs
were just amazing.. I was completly lost in the show during Disintegration
and 100 years and I just knew That Promise was going to be outsatanding
when played live...and I was right.
Over all it was a hell of a show... Personally I was a little
bummed at some of the poppier stuff (especially after seeing the Ohio
setlist) but This was my first show of the tour since we just had a baby
I cant really do the dreamtour thing all over the world...and I am just
happy to see them again. Thay have so much material to draw from at this
point that there will always be something I wished they played...all the
more reason to catch multiple shows when you can...see you in Denver. ONE
more thing... I am so happy seeing all the younger people at concerts getting
turned on to the Cure...but come on people...tap your toes, bob your head
move a little. I have never seen so many zombie like concertgoers. get up
and DANCE its the Cure for ***$$%^ sake!!!!! 32 down and lots more to go...
- Creighton
I'm just back from the show in Mansfield, MA.
Overall it was a show with a good set list, energetic band, but
offset by terrible acoustics and a sleepy crowd.
The different shows started at 5pm, with Head Automatica (giving
a bad performance), certainly not on par with Thursday. Auf der Meur
and Muse
were great, Mogwai was distorted by terrible sound, and Interpol
were not on par with their New York performance.
The cure were slated for 9:15 but started nearly ten minutes
late, causing Robert to break curfew by eight minutes.
There were a lot of free seats in the front-middle section (right
behind the pit), I'm not sure why.
Now for the set...
Show started with a very disappointing version of lost. Thankfully,
a good performance of plainsong served as the real opener. At that point
it became clear the sound is going to spoil the show, you could hardly
hear Robert's voice. He did go around and talked to the crowd in the front
rows of the two side sections.
An ok performance of Fascination Street, followed by a good TEOTW.
Anniversary was a nice surprise, ruined again by really bad sound.
Love song and Inbetween Days were good as always, but the crowd refused
to wake up, standing/leaning against their chairs. Just like heaven
was not too convincing (NY performance was much better), followed by
a disappointing Jupiter Crash. The band and crowd picked up a little
for pictures of you, which was followed by a very disappointing version
of Before 3 (although Robert did go through the whole yeah-yeah-yeah
routine).
Edge of the deep green sea was done nicely but hands went up
mostly in the pit. Disintegration was good (with weird sperm-eggs video
in the background), followed by a great 100 years, and an amazing performance
of The Promise (finally this song got some justice. It was bad in NY).
The band rushed to the first encore, playing M, play for today
(few in the crowd cheered, they were deeply asleep by then), and a great
performance of Forest. The band was already over time, so Robert talked
to someone (stage manager), came back saying that he doesn't mind paying
for breaking curfew, but they're just going to pull the plug, so they
have two minutes. They did a great going nowhere, closing at 11:08. Robert
didn't say much else during the show although he appeared to be in a
pretty good mood. He didn't react when someone in the pit threw a shirt
at him during the encore.
Overall, good performance, disappointing sound and crowd (time
to start importing crowd from the UK or something).
One more thing about the venue: the tweeter center is really
inaccessible without a car. I walked from the train station for 3 miles
with a bunch of other people, who are likely to get stuck there tonight
because the last train was at 10, and there are no taxis in Mansfield.
Me and my friend were saved by two readers of COF, Danielle and Bill,
so I really want to thank them!
- Uri Dekel
17 years ago to the day, as a 17 year
old, I first saw the Cure on the Kissing Tour in Worcester, Massachusetts.
So I guess it was only fitting that tonight, in Mansfield, MA, I
experienced the "17 Seconds Encore" - especially Play For Today which I
had to wait 9 concerts to hear!! What a gorgeous and exceptional show.
The band played with such intensity and emotion, and Smith's voice elicited
a power I have not witnessed since 1992's Wish tour, or possibly even
1989's Prayer tour. After reviewing each night's setlist, I was
torn between Lost and Plainsong as the opener. I consider
Lost to be an assault on the senses - just incredible - and Plainsong
is possibly my favorite Cure song. So when Plainsong followed Lost,
I was floored. It was fucking beautiful. I won't go into
all of the songs, except to say that Smith and the boys gave their all
on every song and the mix was near perfect (the beginning of Before 3 being
the exception, but that quickly cleared up.) 100 years was awesome;
FTEOTDGS was intense (not too many hands in the air though).
The crowd was louder than Robert on the first verse of JLH and even louder
during Play For Today. The Promise blew me away - I love the CD version but
I was amazed how overwhelming it was live - possibly the best song of the
night. When they left the stage
after that one, Robert did his shy smile and appreciative/ extended
gaze at the audience. They returned for the 17 Seconds encore,
and when they
ended that with the "short" version of A Forest, I knew they
were coming back again!! They ended the night with Going Nowhere,
which was a
fantastic and fitting end to the show. The funny
thing about that is that I saw they played it once (in Atlanta) and
having the US version of the CD, I was afraid they might play it tonight
and that I wouldn't know the song!! So I downloaded a live version
from COF a few days ago, and it quickly became one of my favorite new
songs. Overall, it was just a great night and all the boys were
in fine form - even saw a few smiles from Roger and Perry. You can
tell that Smith really appreciates his fans and I love the way he looks
likes he really doesn't want to leave the stage. I always have trouble
hearing what he says, but, thanks in part to the other reviews on COF (!),
I did catch the "Thank you very much, it was fucking excellent"!!
My friend and I arrived at the show shortly before Melissa Auf
Der Maur took the 2nd stage, but right away ran into a guy from our
old neighborhood who we hadn't seen in years (and whose sister sat in
front of me at my very first Cure show!!). So, I ended up not seeing
anyone else on the bill, but Interpol (Joy Division?) certainly sounded
good!!
Thanks, guys, for putting on a great fucking show!!
- Sean
Muse Setlist - Hysteria, Newborn, Bliss,
Butterflies and Hurricanes, Time is Running Out, Stockholm Syndrome
Mmm.....it's good to be Cure fan.
So the day started off pretty well...nice weather, pretty venue,
fairly smooth organization. Mogwai was predictably solid.
Cooper Temple Clause was surprisingly good (The Same Mistakes and New
Toys are great songs) and very interesting (though not as interesting as
Head Automatica's lead singer's dancing). Rapture was OK and Melissa
Auf der Maur was a little embarassing, but she seemed to have a strong
contingent of fans. Interpol was very solid, although the new stuff
(Evil, Narc, Slow Hands) is much weaker than anything off of Turn on the
Bright Lights.
Then came Muse. Muse is such an awesome band, and an amazing
live performance. It's a shame they're so obscure stateside, but
on the other hand that did mean we got to get right up close to the stage.
Their singer has one hell of a voice, and plays a mean guitar, and plays
a mean piano, and has the coolest jacket ever.
Then we shuffled back to the main stage for the final time, and
not long after Robert started wailing about not being able to find himself.
I may think "The Cure" is the weakest album since The Top, but regardless,
from the moment I heard his voice, I realized how meaningless all the
bands that came before were. They were entertaining diversions,
but The Cure's become such a part of my life, that they're as close to
a religious experience as a godless person like me will ever get.
The lushness of Plainsong contrasted nicely with Lost, becoming one of
my favourite moments of the concert (even though the light display was totally
inappropriate for this song...I just closed my eyes). It was also
great to here Anniversary, which I feel is the best of the new songs.
The Promise sounded fantastic live, and FTEOTDGS and Just Like Heaven were
Great. I've never been a huge fan of Inbetween Days or 100 Years,
but both of these songs were performed superbly in their own ways.
Of course it wasn't a perfect concert, and some songs felt disappointingly
tired, like Love Song and Fascination Street. But the performances
got a lot stronger and Robert started talking a little bit
as the set moved out of singles territory. The encore was
a nice trio from 17 Seconds. Then came the real surprise: the band
came back out and told the crowd they had two more minutes before the
staff started pulling out the plugs for their instruments and equipment.
So Robert said they would only do the first verse of a song, and introduced
it as one they didn't typically play. And it was--Going Nowhere!
Woohoo! My second favorite off of The Cure, and a real treat to
hear in live.
Anyway, I'm sure some people will complain about the rushed feeling
of the singles in the first half of the set, or how Robert wasn't as
talkative as at other shows, or how the crowd wasn't going nuts, but I
thought it was a great show and I can't be bothered with imperfections,
cuz I've got a mellow high from having just heard my favorite songs ever
played live by my favorite band ever.
- Bryan